SEASON 2

Part 2 of our deep dive into the murder of Betsy Faria, we pick up where the courtroom left Russ behind — branded a killer, sitting in a prison cell, while the truth continued to scream just outside the record.

In this bonus episode, we open with the most recent twist in the Morgan Geyser Saga — her escape, the brief period she was missing, and the eventual capture that brought her back into custody. We’ll talk about what we know, what’s emerged since, and why the situation has so many people asking hard questions all over again. This is our space to pause, reflect, and unpack the developments before we step back into the story that started it all.

In this episode, we focus on Betsy Faria: a mother, a friend, and a woman fighting through the final chapters of a long cancer battle. We walk through her last day — the chemo appointment, the holiday plans, and the small decisions that seemed ordinary at the time but would become chilling in hindsight.

This episode examines Thad’s extraordinary will to survive, the chilling behavior of his attacker, and how one boy’s courage changed the course of a horrifying case.

In this episode, we revisit the life of a young woman whose disappearance shook her community and sparked questions that still demand answers. We walk back through the timeline, the investigation, the suspects, and the quiet details that were overlooked the first time around.

As the courtroom prepares to open its doors, Mia’s case is more important than ever. This is a chance to remember what’s at stake — justice, truth, and a voice for Mia.

Tune in, refresh your memory, and get ready for what comes next in the fight for accountability.

In April 1981, the small mountain town of Keddie, California, was shattered by a scene straight out of a nightmare. Inside Cabin 28, a mother, her teenage son, and his friend were brutally murdered — while a young daughter vanished without a trace.

Before Scream terrified audiences, a real-life horror unfolded in the quiet college town of Gainesville, Florida. In 1990, five students were brutally murdered over just four days — their lives stolen by a man the media would dub “The Gainesville Ripper.” But behind the headlines and the Hollywood inspiration were real people — Sonja Larson, Christina Powell, Christa Hoyt, Tracy Paules, and Manuel Taboada — young, vibrant students with dreams, laughter, and futures waiting to unfold.

🕯️ This is the story of Lisa Ann French — the little girl who changed Halloween, and the community that still carries her memory forward.

In the winter of 1977, Sacramento became the setting of a nightmare. A series of brutal murders left the city paralyzed with fear — and behind it all was a man the media would come to call The Vampire Killer, Richard Chase.

Join us as we dig into the Killer Clown Craze — the viral phenomenon that blurred the line between internet myth and real-world menace. We’ll uncover where it began, how far it spread, and why so many people were left wondering if laughter and terror were closer than anyone realized.

In the summer of 2017, in a quiet Ohio suburb, a secret came to light that stunned the nation. Eighteen-year-old Brooke Skylar Richardson was accused of hiding her pregnancy, giving birth alone in her bathroom, and burying her newborn daughter in the backyard while her family slept just feet away. The media frenzy that followed centered on Skylar—her appearance, her lifestyle, and her courtroom demeanor. But lost beneath the headlines was the story of the true victim: a baby girl who lived only moments, if at all, before her life was taken from her.

Fingerprinting revolutionized criminal investigations-but its history is filled with surprising twists. In this episode, we dive into the infamous case of Will West and William West, two men whose identical appearances exposed the flaws of early identification systems and helped cement fingerprints as the gold standard in forensics. From there we explore the curious world of twin-related crimes: Do identical twins share the same fingerprint? Can twins be charged for the same murder? Join us as we unravel the fascinating intersection of history, science, and true crime, where identity isn't always as clear as it seems.

In July 2014, German tourist Lars Mittank’s dream vacation in Bulgaria spiraled into a nightmare. After a bar fight left him injured, Lars began acting strangely, calling his mother in fear claiming he was being followed. His last known moments were captured on Airport security cameras: a sudden and frantic sprint out of the airport terminal before disappearing in the field beyond. Nearly a decade later, no trace of him has ever been found. In this episode, we explore the eerie final days of Lars Mittank, the countless theories about what happened, and why his disappearance remains one of the most haunting mysteries on the internet. 

In 1990 Marlene Warren opened her front door to find a clown holding balloons and flowers. Moments later she was shot in cold blood. For decades her murder haunted her Florida community-twisting through rumors, betrayal, and a shocking love triangle. Join us as we unravel the chilling case of Marlene Warren, the “killer clown” murder that remained unsolved for nearly three decades

In July 1951, 67 year old Mary Reeser was found in her Florida apartment under circumstances so bizarre they left police, the FBI, and fire experts completely stumped. Her body had been reduced to ashes except for one slipper clad foot, while the rest of the room remained almost untouched. In this episode we unravel the chilling mystery of “The Cinder Woman” and the strange legacy of one of history's most unsettling unsolved deaths.

In December of 2004, the quiet town of Skidmore Missouri was shattered by a crime so brutal and bizarre it stunned the nation. Bobbi Jo Stinnett, a vibrant young woman expecting her first child, was brutally murdered in her own home. What investigators uncovered was even more disturbing- a calculated act of violence fueled by lies, obsession, and an unimaginable motive.

She feared he might kill her and one night, he did. The brutal murder of Amie Harwick revealed a chilling pattern of stalking, obsession, and violence. Amie, a Hollywood therapist, was known for her work helping others heal, but behind the scenes she was fighting for her own safety. Join us as we dive into her story, accomplishments and the threats she faced leading up to that tragic night.

In this haunting episode, we go beyond the headlines to remember the victims of Hugo Selenski — the Pennsylvania man whose name became synonymous with horror after a mass grave was discovered in his Luzerne County backyard in 2003. While much of the media spotlight focused on Selenski’s strange behavior, jailbreaks, and courtroom theatrics, we turn our focus to the lives he destroyed.

November 1994 Marty Grisham was shot 4 times after answering a knock at his front door, his girlfriend Barbara sat just feet away in the living room. Police quickly found their prime suspect or did they? Join us as we unravel all the twists and turns in the still unsolved murder of Marty Grisham, and the long long road to justice for the wrongfully convicted Michael Clark.

January 23rd 2007, 37 year old Heather Garraus was leaving work when someone wearing a mask forced her to her knees and shot her execution style in front of her coworkers. The investigation into who could have done this to Heather, lead investigators and the town of Greeley Colorado down a dark rabbit hole of lies, love triangles, affairs, and scandal within the police department. 

Yvonne Woods, who

In 1980 Dorothy Scott vanished after taking her coworker to the hospital, weeks later her family began receiving disturbing phone calls from someone claiming to have her. Months later her car was found burned, and years later her remains were discovered. Join us as we dive deep into the details of Dorothy’s disappearance, the strange phone calls, and the lingering questions that still haunt this cold case.

Todays episode is both baffling and heartbreaking: the disappearance of Cindy Song. A bright and ambitious Penn State student, Cindy vanished without a trace back in 2001. What makes this case so haunting is the lack of solid leads and the many theories paired with unanswered questions surrounding her last known movements. 

Audrey Backeberg was just 20 years old when she kissed her children goodbye one summer morning and was never seen again. vanishing into the void. No trace. No note. Just silence. Whispers swirled around her town: had she met with foul play? Run off with someone? Or fallen victim to the unknown?

In 2011 Ellen Greenberg, a 27 year old teacher was found dead in her apartment by her fiancé Sam Goldberg. Ellen's death was initially determined to be a homicide, eventually being ruled a suicide. Ellen's parents have been fighting for justice ever since, 14 years later they have done the impossible. Join us today as we explore the mysterious death of Ellen Greenberg and try to answer the question that has been asked for over a decade. What really happened in that apartment?

Welcome back to part 2 of our update episode, where we give updates on cases we covered in season 1. Some of these cases have some big updates. While others leave us with more questions than we had before. 

Today’s episode is going to be a little different. We decided that it was time to do an update episode, where we give yall updates on cases we covered in season 1. Some of these cases have some big updates while others leave us with more questions than we had before. 

We know we had a lot of episodes in season 1 and we don't expect you to remember every detail so we will give a brief recap with each update to jog your memory. We highly recommend going back and listening to any case you're not familiar with. Because there is so much more to each of these cases than what we will be giving in our recaps. 

One moment, he was calmly walking along a quiet road. Just a voice on the line with his parents. Then, a sudden exclamation… and silence. When 19-year-old Brandon Swanson disappeared into the night, he left behind only questions, a stranded car, and a mystery that still haunts Minnesota. 

January 2022, 8 year old Elizabeth Struhs suffered for 5 days through a 100 percent preventable death. While her Mother and Father, along with members of their cult-like church The Saints, stood by and watched. Join us and Elizabeth's sister Jayde in fighting for justice for Elizabeth!

Katie Pladl was a talented and compassionate young woman with a passion for art and a bright future ahead. But her journey to reconnect with her biological family took a dark and tragic turn—leading to a shocking case of incest, murder, and national heartbreak.

We are back with part 2 of Justice For Maggie Long, if you haven't already listened to Part 1, Definitely go give it a listen before diving into this episode. 

17 year old Maggie Long's life was tragically cut short just weeks before her 18th birthday. 8 years later Maggie's family is still searching for answers and Justice for Maggie. We had the honor to sit down and talk with Maggie’s sisters Connie and Lynna, to learn more about Maggie, her story, and how we can help her family in their pursuit for justice.

17 year old Maggie Long's life was tragically cut short just weeks before her 18th birthday. 8 years later Maggie's family is still searching for answers and Justice for Maggie. We had the honor to sit down and talk with Maggie’s sisters Connie and Lynna, to learn more about Maggie, her story, and how we can help her family in their pursuit for justice.