Mar 31, 2026
The small town of Hartford, Wisconsin was shaken to its core when 19-year-old college freshman and rising theater star Jesse Blodgett was found murdered in her own home. What first appeared to be an unthinkable tragedy quickly unraveled into something even more disturbing—an obsession that turned deadly.
As investigators dug deeper, they uncovered a chilling connection between Jesse and her killer, Daniel Bartelt, a former classmate whose fixation had been quietly growing in the shadows. Through digital clues, surveillance, and disturbing evidence, law enforcement pieced together a crime fueled by fantasy, rejection, and control.
In this episode, we break down the timeline of that night, the investigation that led to a swift arrest, and the haunting details that left a community searching for answers. Who was Jesse Blodgett beyond the headlines? And how did someone so close to her world become her killer?
This is a story of talent, promise, and a life stolen far too soon—and a stark reminder of how dangerous obsession can become when it goes unchecked.
Join us LIVE in Colorado Springs on April 16th at 6PM for a special_Justice For…_live show at Voodoo Brewing! 🎙️🍻
Come hang out, talk true crime, and experience the show in person.
🎟️ Grab your tickets now:https://www.justiceforpodcast.com/event-list*– we can’t wait to see you there!*
Disclaimer
The views and opinions expressed in this podcast are those of the hosts and do not necessarily reflect the views of any affiliated organizations. All suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. This podcast is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice or a substitute for professional consultation.
Show Notes
RAW VIDEO: Daniel Bartelt`s statement to court prior to sentencing | FOX6 Milwaukee daniel sentencing video to upload
Victim/Witness Impact Statement: Buck Blodgett, Jessie’s Dad | The LOVE>hate Project
20180517122512486_Bartelt cert petition.pdf
What We Do | The LOVE>hate Project | Presentations | Programs
LOVEISGREATERTHANhateCRIMINALCOMPLAINT.pdf
The death of Jessie Blodgett: How a teenage friendship turned deadly - ABC News
